5 ways to use the same rubric for different activities.
View this email as a web page here.
Faculty Focus

By Stephanie Almagno, PhD

English teachers know a few things about managing the paper load. But managing isn’t leading. We should do more than manage the load; we should lead our students through the writing process (invention, drafting, and revising) to help them become independent thinkers who can effectively present their ideas to an audience.

Rubrics offer an effective way to guide thinking and learning in any writing-intensive course.

HINT: Distribute the assignment sheet and rubric at the same time that you introduce a writing assignment. Students need this concrete information from the onset for self-improvement at all stages of the writing process. Your rubric should be clear enough that students understand your expectations even when you are not available for consultation.

Here are five different ways to apply the same rubric in your classroom.

1. A Rubric for Thinking (Invention Activity)

  • Immediately following the initial discussion of a writing assignment and its corresponding rubric, allow students to work independently for a few moments, generating their initial ideas for their papers.
  • After brainstorming, direct students to reflect on the rubric to encourage additional responses to the topic at hand. The rubric should spark thinking.

Hint: Work with struggling students during this process. Demonstrate ways to use the rubric to flesh out their initial responses. This is your time to answer authentic questions one-on-one.

 2. A Rubric for Peer Feedback (Drafting Activity)

  • Vomit drafts. Teachers don’t like to read them, so let the students read each other’s and score them against the rubric.
  • Use rubrics for peer feedback at all stages of the writing process. If today is the day to review use of secondary sources and subsequent citations, pair students and set them to work.
  • Students should respond to each other’s work using the verbiage in the assigned domains. Based on peer feedback, students should make adjustments and enhance their use of sources.
  • Students can score their use of sources/citations against the rubric and discuss why these elements earn the grade they do. Remember, grades are earned, not given. Students should be able to align their essays and their components with established rubric categories and indicators.
  • Use guided peer feedback throughout the writing process as homework or in class.

Hint: Rubrics should contain a discrete space for the name of the peer editor.

Rubrics help you develop a better grading system, one that delivers fair results, helps students learn, and makes effective use of your time. In this program, you will get examples of the three basic formats for rubrics and explore seven key recommendations developed to help you transform the grading process. Learn More »

3. A Rubric for Teacher Feedback (Revision Activity)

  • In this use of the rubric, you are offering a mulligan, a “do over”—students will appreciate this. Don’t worry about attributing points or grades to each domain on the rubric; instead, simply provide feedback. You are telling students, in so many words, “what works” and “what needs work.”
  • Use symbols to convey quality of work. Stars and checkmarks indicate areas of strength. Or consistently use three emoticons: smile, meh, and frown. The emoticons speed up your response time, and while they provide authentic feedback, symbols don’t carry the same weight as a red-inked D. Reserve comments for clarification/remediation or indication of remarkable insight.

HINT: Student projects should include multiple drafts (look for development of ideas). Also collect peer feedback rubrics; “eyeball” these to ascertain the quality of student responses. Remember, teaching students to be good editors takes time and training.

4. A Rubric for Mini-Lessons (Data Indicate a Teachable Moment)

  • Most teachers miss this use of rubrics. Prepare mini-lessons for authentic and immediate feedback to the entire class based on data gleaned from the rubric.
  • After you respond to a set of papers, scan the rubric for the categories where the greatest number of students demonstrated proficiency and, conversely, showed need of remediation. Prepare mini-lessons to refresh or reteach the skills in the weakest category.
  • Use students who excelled in this category to lead the discussion of the element being remediated.
  • After a mini-lesson, students will have a better understanding of ways to improve the skill being discussed in the context of their own essays; this should lead to higher scores in that category and in subsequent revisions.

HINT: Return papers before the mini-lesson so students know that this lesson is for them.

5. A Rubric for Making Grades Visible (Student Investment in Grading)

  • When students submit projects for grading, they should attach the rubric they used to score themselves. This combats the erroneous idea that grading criteria is vague or invisible.
  • With this use, students assess their own strengths, weaknesses, and areas for revision.
  • The teacher, in turn, responds to the projects on the same rubric. This is a check for inter-rater reliability. If the teacher and the student are close in their assessments, only moderate intervention is needed. But if the teacher and the student issue markedly different scores for a category, then remediation is needed—usually in the form of a quick in-class conference.

Hint: Always respond in a signature ink color. It should stand out against the students’ writing.

How often have we heard that students believe grades to be arbitrary or capricious? Repeated use of a single rubric is good for both students and instructors. Switching roles between author and editor results in students’ increased familiarity with the process and the components of good writing. Over the course of the semester, students will synthesize the rubric’s components into effective communication. The instructor, too, will shift from “sage on the stage” to “guide on the side,” answering fewer questions (and answering the same question fewer times). In other words, students will gain greater independence as writers and thinkers. And this is good for all of us.

Stephanie Almagno is associate dean of the School of Arts & Sciences at Piedmont College. 

Magna Publications

If you think using rubrics in grading is like coloring within the lines, think again, and check out How Can Rubrics Make Grading Easier and Faster?, a 20 Minute Mentor.

You’ll get examples of the three basic formats for rubrics and explore seven key recommendations developed to help you transform the grading process. You’ll see how using rubrics can help you give better feedback in less time.

Your presenter, Linda Suskie, is not only an internationally recognized speaker, writer, and workshop facilitator on higher education, she’s a bit of a renegade when it comes to rubrics. To her, rubrics aren’t about rules, they’re about establishing what you’re looking for when assessing student assignments and setting guidelines for scoring student work.

This fast and focused presentation will give you an overview of rubric formats and show you how to adapt them to meet the needs of your teaching style and your students. In just 20 minutes, you’ll learn how you can use rubrics to upgrade your assessment process and save time.

This program explains:

  • Tips to limit the amount of time you spend grading
  • How rubrics can help you guide student learning
  • Techniques to control the volume of graded assignments
  • What to do with careless student work
  • Practices to engage students in scoring assignments
  • How rubrics and self-checklists can boost student achievement
  • Guidelines on determining the overall grade

Grading is an essential element of your job. Why not learn how to do it better and faster and transform it into something that can help students learn? Order How Can Rubrics Make Grading Easier and Faster?

Learn More

2718 Dryden Dr.    Madison,  WI  53704  United States

You received this email because you are subscribed to Faculty Focus - MWF from Faculty Focus.
Update your email preferences to choose the type(s) of email you receive, or to unsubscribe from future emails.

Please do not reply to this email; this address is not monitored. If you have a question or concern, contact our customer service team at support@magnapubs.com or 608-246-3590. For editorial, contact mary.bart@facultyfocus.com.